Rate GE's FF team!

Schaut auf den ersten Blick ganz in Ordnung aus:smile2:

QB:

Da hast du mit McNabb und Palmer zwei zuverlässige Punktelieferanten bekommen, die du je nach Matchup aufstellen kannst. Mit Delhomme ein Backup, mehr aber auch nicht, sollte aber im Normalfall egal sein wer 3.QB ist.

RB:

Mit Mendenhall hast du dir einen guten RB1 geholt, der dir dank seiner Rolle bei den Steelers genug Punkte bringen wird. Danach wirds aber etwas eng, mit Williams und Addai zwei Spieler die mir zu riskant wären, da ist von gut bis miserabel alles drin. Der Huggins Move könnte Gold wert sein, gute Wahl.

WR:

Das Prunkstück deines Teams, besser gehts nicht. Die zwei besten Spieler auf dieser Position, Respekt. Dahinter hast du mit Aromashodu einen Spieler dem ich ne Breakout Season zutraue, Mike Williams kann überraschen und Rice wird nach seiner Verletzungspause auch noch schön Punkte auflegen.

TE:

Mit Celek bestens besetzt, passt.

Was in meinen Augen nicht nötig gewesen wäre, waren die 3 Picks für einen Backup Kicker, eine Backup Defense und einen 3. QB. Diese Postionen kann man auch während der Saison noch über die Waiver abdecken. Diese Picks hätte ich jetzt lieber in die Skill Positions gesteckt.
Aber ansonsten hast du ein gutes Team gedraftet das dir genug Siege einbringen wird.

So, dann wollen wir mal:

QB: Gutes Mittelmaß, mehr aber auch nicht.

RB: Auch mittelmäßig. Mendenhall ist mir nach der Verletzung von Willie Colon ein bisschen suspekt, sollte aber dennoch solide sein. Addai seh ich als soliden RB 2. Caddy und Huggins sind als RB 3 ein nettes Paar, letztern hab ich mir auch ein paar mal gesichert.

WR: FlitzdieKatz, das ist doch was. Bist du einer PPR-Liga? Da geht was mit den beiden! Eindeutig die Stärke deines Teams!

TE: Jau, auch gut mit dabei, passt.

K: Kicker halt.

D: Eagles werden hoch gerankt, meines Erachtens fast zu hoch. Aber, das weißt du ja selber.

Ich hab dein Team mal bei footballguys.com raten lassen und es kam folgendes raus:

Zitat

Overview:

Your receivers are the strongest part of this team and you look good at tight end as well. It's rare for us to endorse a team with weaknesses at quarterback and running back, but we're doing it right here! You should have a contender here. But your margin for error in terms of inseason management could be a bit thinner than some of your competitors'. You must remain committed to finding 2010's emergent players at RB and QB.

Players we particularly like on this team include Mike Williams, Cadillac Williams, the Dolphins defense, Dan Carpenter, the Eagles defense, and David Akers. We have all these guys ranked ahead of where they are typically being drafted.

Bottom line:
With great inseason management, we think you have about a 85 percent chance of making the playoffs.
With good inseason management, we think you have about a 75 percent chance of making the playoffs.
With average inseason management, we think you have a 66 percent chance of making the playoffs.

In any event, we wish you the best of luck. Here's hoping all your weeks are like week 2 of 2007:

Carson Palmer vs. CLE: 401 passing yards, 6 TD
Andre Johnson vs. CAR: 120 receiving yards, 2 TD
Randy Moss vs. SD: 105 receiving yards, 2 TD
Cadillac Williams vs. NO: 61 combined yards, 2 TD
Jake Delhomme vs. HOU: 307 passing yards, 3 TD

QB Summary:

We have Carson Palmer rated #15 among quarterbacks, so we're not even sold on him as a fantasy starter in your league. But #16-rated QB Donovan McNabb provides you with another viable option. So while the position doesn't figure to be a strength, with shrewd management and a little luck you might end up with decent production at QB

Incidentally, these two have a pretty nice combined schedule and a decent playoff schedule too. If you simply played the one with the better matchup each week, this is the schedule you'd face:
NE | HOU | STL | CLE | GB | IND | ATL | DET | PIT | PHI | TEN | MIN | NO | TB | CLE | JAX

Jake Delhomme is a solid depth pick.

Note that the above "thoughts" were generated by David Dodds's projections. Others have different takes:

Some of our staffers have Carson Palmer as high as #9, which would make him a fine first quarterback. Matt Waldman's take: "If Palmer's arm was still an issue I believe the Bengals would have been more urgent about finding quality back ups or draft picks to fill the depth chart. The addition of Terrell Owens, Antonio Bryant, Jordan Shipley and Matt Jones suggests the Bengals know they have a strong ground game, but they need to get back that dynamic passing game they once had just a few seasons ago. With Terrell Owens, I'm convinced this team should return to a more dynamic passing game. It doesn't mean they won't run the ball a lot, but I expect to see more balance and better returns for Palmer. "

RB Summary:

We see both your starters at running back as below average. Our projections have Rashard Mendenhall ranked ninth and Joseph Addai ranked 22nd.

Your bench looks good and should help offset the unexciting starting unit. Cadillac Williams should serve as a very solid third running back. We also see Kareem Huggins as an above average RB4.

We're not sure Mewelde Moore would otherwise be roster-worthy, but he's good insurance for Mendenhall.

Note that the above "thoughts" were generated by David Dodds's projections. Others have different takes:

Some of our staffers have Rashard Mendenhall as high as #7, which would make him an above average first running back. Anthony Borbely's take: "Mendenhall is primed to vault close to the top 5 RBs this year. He will be an every down back and has solid receiving skills as well. Expect the Steelers to run the ball a lot more this year."

Joseph Addai is ranked #15 by some of our writers, which would make him an above average second running back. Jason Wood reasons, "Addai has been a Top 12 fantasy RB in three of the last four seasons, the other (2008), he was injured. Yet it seems fantasy owners are always looking for reasons to discount this guy. You don't need Addai to be a 280-300 carry back to put up huge numbers. He was a Top 10 back last year in spite of just 215 carries in 15 games. He's a fantastic RB2 that can be had later than he should."

WR Summary:

Nice work here. We like both your starting receivers, as our projections indicate that they give you a combined 5.8 point-per-game advantage over an average opponent in this league. Andre Johnson is our #1 ranked receiver, and we have Randy Moss at #3.

Your bench also looks good. Mike Williams looks great as a third receiver. Devin Aromashodu should be adequate at WR4.

We're not sure that Sidney Rice adds much, as you're already strong at the position and we aren't convinced he's roster-worthy in this league anyway.

Note that the above "thoughts" were generated by David Dodds's projections. Others have different takes:

Some members of our staff have Devin Aromashodu ranked as high as 30th, which would make him a great fourth receiver and even a legitimate WR3. Matt Waldman defends his high ranking as follows: "I continue to read that Devin Aromashodu doesn't fit the body type of a Mike Martz receiver and that he is still inconsistent. Maybe he's still inconsistent compared to Reggie Wayne, a receiver who was quoted in January 2010 as saying Aromashodu has the potential to be a very good starter in this league. Jay Cutler loves him, lobbied for him to get playing time and had the confidence in him to throw him the ball in clutch situations in the two big starts the receiver had late last year. I'm not expecting him to be a top-12 receiver this year, but anything less than No.3 WR fantasy production will be a disappointment in a Martz offense that can support three 1000-yard receivers. I think 800 yards and 8 scores is very possible for Aromashodu, good enough for top-30 production. "

Sidney Rice is ranked #29 by some of our writers, which would make him a great fifth receiver and even a legitimate WR3. John Norton reasons, "The lingering hip injury is enough to drop him a few slots but once he shows us that he's healthy its back to the top 10 for Rice. Especially now that Favre is back. "

TE Summary:

Brent Celek should be above average as a starting tight end. We have him ranked seventh overall at the position. Tony Scheffler is a nice backup.

Note that the above "thoughts" were generated by David Dodds's projections. Others have different takes:

Some of our staffers have Tony Scheffler as high as #15, which would make him an above average second tight end. Anthony Borbely's take: "Scheffler has a lot of talent and should easily be a high-end TE2 with upside this year. He could not ask for a much better situation. "

Kicker Summary:

With David Akers and Dan Carpenter, you should be above average at the position.

Defense Summary:

We think the Eagles are the #2 defense in the league, at about 0.8 points per game above average. You probably don't need a backup.

Alles anzeigen

Kenne ja nicht Euer scoring Verfahren, aber wenn es auch Punkte für Returns gibt, dann hätte ich da noch bei den WR nach einem geschaut.

RB muss man wirklich schauen, da ja Deine Starter da doch immer wieder mit Verletzungen auffallen.

Bei Deinen QBs musst Du aber wirklich von Woche zu Woche schauen wer aufläuft.

Dass der Addai in einer 14er-Liga mit 3 Keepern in Runde 4 noch da war, find ich ja schon irgendwie hart.

Zitat von GermanEagle

Cadillac ist nach Berichten so fit wie eh und je

Das wäre eher schlecht
Aber er hat sich im TC so präsentiert wie in seiner RotY-Saison

Bei 3 Keepern ist es nicht so eng, aber mir fehlt etwas das zukünftige Keeper Potenzial deiner Picks. Statt Delhomme hätte ich da auf Glück einen Bradford geholt. Aber wie gesagt bei 3 Keepern müsste Bradford schon aus rasten.

Kommt drauf an, wen er 2011 dann noch keepern kann. Johnson und Moss sind da meines Erachtens Locks. Dann noch nen RB und gut ist. Hat dann in der Situation keinen Sinn, nen Rookie QB zu holen, den man den eh nicht keepern kann, weil er auch im zweiten Jahr noch nicht so gut sein wird, dass er die eigentlich vorgesehenen überholt.

Zitat von GermanEagle

Longhorn

in unserer Liga darfst du maximal 6 RBs oder 6 WRs haben. Nen backup Kicker und backup Defense brauchst du schon alleine wegen der bye-week. Die Regel, dass man noch nach der Draft auf dem waiver zuschlagen kann, gilt in unserer Liga nicht. Sprich du musst an diesem Draft-Day alles draften.

Wow, von so einer Liga habe ich noch nie gehört. Bedeutet das, dass alle Spieler, die nicht gedraftet wurden, nie in irgendein Team aufgenommen werden können? Und dass alle Teams von Saisonbeginn bis -ende den komplett gleichen Roster behalten? Stelle ich mir nicht gerade sinnvoll vor, damit eliminierst du mit dem In-Season-Managament ja direkt einen grossen Teil von Fantasy Football.